Michigan Election Integrity Experts Detail How the 2020 Election Was Stolen in Detroit

Detroit’s 2020 Election Draws National Media Attention

Phil O’Halloran, one of our own, has been spotlighted by other news organizations, presenting findings from months of investigation into how voter fraud occurred and how ballot security broke down during Detroit’s 2020 election. Speaking with Patty McMurray of 100 Percent Fed Up and Jim Hoft of The Gateway Pundit, O’Halloran outlined a portion of what his team uncovered.

100 Percent Fed Up publication logo
100 Percent Fed Up
The Gateway Pundit publication icon
The Gateway Pundit
Read the Gateway Pundit Article Visit 100 Percent Fed Up

How Ballot Chain of Custody Is Supposed to Work

Before the turmoil at Detroit’s TCF Center, many Michigan voters reasonably believed that transporting thousands of ballots between locations during a presidential election would involve armored vehicles, police escorts, and senior officials monitoring every step. At the very least, they expected each transfer to be carefully documented. That expectation was not met.

During the 2020 General Election, ballot security at the TCF Center was virtually nonexistent. Yet a proper chain of custody is the bedrock of ballot security and, by extension, of every honest election. Absentee voting inherently requires ballots to move from the voter to at least one processing facility, then to a counting board, and finally to storage. The Postal Service covers the first leg; elected city and township clerks are responsible for the remainder.

A sound chain of custody calls for at least two workers on every transfer, armed with clipboards and bills of lading that record ballot counts, times, and signatures at both departure and arrival, along with someone confirming that every ballot sent actually arrived and that none were added en route. In short, basic election integrity principles call for a complete accounting of ballot movements. Remarkably, Michigan law does not mandate it — and in Detroit, chain of custody turned out to be pure fantasy.

There was effectively no meaningful chain of custody as thousands of voted absentee ballots traveled from any of 30 satellite centers or drop boxes to the Detroit Department of Elections (DOE) on West Grand Blvd, or between the DOE and the TCF Center on Washington Blvd in Downtown Detroit.

Documented Incidents from November 2

O’Halloran’s team documented the following activity in Detroit that day.

1:44 PM — Blank Ballots Carried Through the Alley

Ballot trackers Steve Orsini and Tim Mahoney were watching proceedings from the alley behind the Department of Elections when a man appeared carrying a stack of roughly 100 ballots in the open, with no cover or container. He said he was delivering blank ballots to the Coleman A. Young Center several miles away. Traveling alone, he was asked whether he had transfer papers or chain of custody documents. He gave no answer, but said he had already made the trip five times that day and added, “I have been doing this all week.”

Mahoney passed the incident along to GOP challenger and ballot tracker Phil O’Halloran, who drove to the Coleman A. Young Satellite Voting Center about two hours later. There, he asked the supervisor whether anyone had dropped off blank ballots. She replied that a young lady had come earlier with some ballots. When pressed about the man with the hundred blank ballots from the DOE, she abruptly said she was too busy and asked him to leave. [Orsini, Steve, affidavit, O’Halloran, P. Author’s statement]

Unsecured blank ballots in Detroit
Blank ballots moved without a secure container

Michigan Election Law, Sec. 716

Michigan Election law states: 168.716 Absent voters and other ballots; wrapping, sealing. Sec. 716 — The ballots of each kind for each election precinct shall be wrapped and secured in 2 separate packages. Each package shall be securely sealed with a red paper seal furnished by the secretary of state and shall bear on its wrapper the name and number of the precinct and a certificate signed by the county clerk or some member of the board of county election commissioners or his or its duly authorized agent, setting forth the number and kind of ballots in such package and that such ballots were counted, packaged, and sealed by himself personally, or by his duly authorized agent.

2:02 PM — The Dolly and the Open Box

In the same alley behind Election HQ, Orsini and Mahoney saw another man pushing a dolly with five boxes across from the loading dock. Orsini noted the man had come out of the DOE building. One box was open and appeared to contain ballots. When Orsini and Mahoney politely asked what was in the boxes and where he was going, the man became very upset, began yelling at them, turned the dolly around, and wheeled the boxes back to the loading dock.

Man with a dolly behind the Detroit Department of Elections
Man with the dolly in the alley behind the DOE

About TCF Timeline: The 2020 General Election in Detroit

These and other little-known facts from the scandalous 2020 Election are revealed in riveting detail in TCF Timeline: the 2020 General Election in Detroit, soon to be released by Michigan Citizens for Election Integrity (MC4EI.com).

The report’s author, Philip O’Halloran, served as a GOP challenger at TCF during the 2018 General and 2020 Primary Elections, where he saw no chain of custody safeguards in the transportation of thousands of ballots. Ahead of the November 2020 General Election, he formed an informal group of roughly 30 “ballot trackers,” mostly Republican volunteers, to observe activity at many of the 23 satellite voting centers and 30 drop boxes around Detroit during the four weeks before the Election.

Exclusive Excerpt: Back Alley Blank Ballots

November 2nd — More ballots are transferred from the DOE to the TCF Center in large Penske trucks. Poor, if any, chain of custody methods are employed. No log entries record the number of ballots transported, times, or names of transporters. Ballots are moved in open USPS trays (or in no container at all — see below) without a lid or any way to lock the contents.

Truck used to move ballots in Detroit
Ballots moved by truck in Detroit
Penske truck parked near the Detroit Department of Elections
Penske truck near the DOE

Watch Phil O’Halloran and election expert Linda Lee Tarver of Tarver Consulting explain in detail how the vote was stolen in the city of Detroit.

Timeline Excerpt: Broken Chain of Custody

Here is a portion of the timeline discussed in the interview, covering multiple cases of broken chain of custody with ballots in the city of Detroit.

Approximately 4:45 PM — GOP affiant and credentialed challenger Poplawski, having waited outside the counting board since 12 noon, leaves the TCF Center without having been able to perform his duties as a challenger.

4:55 PM — Having been removed from the TCF Center by Detroit police for an alleged rules infraction on the orders of election official Chris Thomas, ballot tracker and affiant Philip O’Halloran arrives at the Department of Elections to meet fellow ballot trackers who had been observing ballot movements in the days before the election. There he notices a large Penske truck parked on Third Avenue facing north, a few feet from the alley leading behind the DOE’s rear loading dock. Behind it is a large white City of Detroit pickup truck with two men inside. O’Halloran asks them if there are ballots in the Penske truck. The driver states that the truck is empty. After photographing both trucks, O’Halloran leaves the area. [The author’s affidavit, c. November 15th, 2020]

The Detroit Department of Elections building on West Grand Blvd in August 2021 is election headquarters, where mailed ballots and those from over 20 satellite voting centers are received, processed, and transported to the AV Counting Board at the TCF Center. Note the return of the drop boxes, which, according to critics, facilitate illegal ballot harvesting.

Guarding an Empty Truck

Approximately 9:30 PM — further observations from the timeline are detailed in the full report.

Explore More Election Integrity Coverage

Stay Connected with MC4EI

Reach out by phone at 1-248-345-1959 or email [email protected].

Disclaimer Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions Sitemap

MC4EI continues to document what happened in Detroit during the 2020 election so that voters, clerks, and lawmakers can see where ballot security failed. The accounts above — from alley observations to the TCF timeline — are drawn from the team’s research and affidavits. Explore the related coverage below to follow the full record.