A Patriot’s Reflections on the 2022 Mi GOP State Convention

Reflecting Conservatively on the 2022 Michigan GOP State Convention

Joe Brandis, President of MC4EI, authored this piece, which first ran in 100% Fed Up on August 30, 2026. He walks through how the 2022 Michigan Republican State Convention played out and honors three conservative women who gave their all to the movement.

Read the Original Article

How the 2022 State Convention Process Unfolded

The 2022 Republican State Convention now belongs to history, and what struck me most was how well the process ultimately worked. As an elected precinct delegate for Oakland's 11th District, I stood on the floor of the Lansing Center as the excitement played out. The proceedings were contentious and dragged on longer than anyone wanted, yet in the end I believe the result reflected the will of the delegates.

Macomb County's Two Rival Delegations

Macomb County showed up with two competing delegations both seeking to be seated. The dispute went back to the removal of Mark Forton as Chair at an April 2022 Macomb County Convention, after which Eric Castiglia was voted in as the convention's Chair. Beyond chairing that convention, there was also an effort to install Castiglia as County Chair in place of Mark Forton. Two rival factions thus emerged, each claiming to represent the Macomb County Republican Party under separate Chairs. By August, two Macomb County Conventions had taken place — one led by Castiglia and one by Forton — and each elected its own slate to the State Convention. That is the backdrop for the fight over which slate should be seated.

At the State Convention, MIGOP recognized and seated the Castiglia delegation, while the Forton delegation went unrecognized and sat in the gallery. Emotions ran high, with plenty of yelling and booing from the convention floor. A motion was raised to recognize the Forton group as the delegation replacing the Castiglia-led one. The State GOP Chairman, who presided over the Convention, proposed to set aside any consideration of the debate. After consultation, each side got 30 seconds to make its case — far too little to properly clarify the issues. The Convention Chairman had favored the Castiglia delegation, but the overwhelming dismay from delegates stopped him from deciding the matter unilaterally without full input from precinct delegates across the state. "We the people" sent a loud message to party leadership. A vote followed, and 88% of delegates backed Forton's delegates. Notably, several delegates removed from the Castiglia delegation were then reinstated within the Forton group.

I am not from Macomb County, but I have talked with people I know on both sides. It is possible that both sides have a point. It could be that Forton needed to be removed — among the reasons cited was his withdrawal of his and the vice chair's personal endorsement of Matt DePerno, the GOP candidate for Attorney General, and it has been widely reported that Forton backed a third-party candidate for Governor. The difficulty was that the removal was not clearly carried out in a legally sound way, though a legal loophole might have existed. I believe many delegates at the convention were not judging Forton or Castiglia personally but rather the process by which Forton was removed.

The Lieutenant Governor Vote and Shane Hernandez

The grassroots won a floor victory, which surely spelled trouble for electing Shane Hernandez as Lieutenant Governor — even though he was Tudor Dixon's pick as the GOP Gubernatorial candidate and was endorsed by DePerno and Trump. Rumblings persisted among delegates that someone else might be a better choice. Nevertheless, the matter went to a vote, and Hernandez won easily with 80% support.

I was asked how this could happen. I believe a large contingent of those who voted to elevate Forton's delegation did so because they felt the process of removing him as Chair was flawed. My view is that even if he was removed at the April Convention according to the letter of the law — which remains debatable — it simply did not appear to be done fairly or transparently. Had the call to the April Macomb County Convention specifically listed on its agenda that a vote would be held to remove Mark Forton, it might have been perceived as fair. To my knowledge, that was not done. Had it been, delegates would have had the chance to ensure both competing sides were present for the vote. Instead, confusion reigned as two Macomb County conventions were held and delegates were unsure which was the correct one to attend. Consequently, many delegates at the August Convention felt the removal process was unfair. That same delegation then voted overwhelmingly to support Shane Hernandez for Lieutenant Governor.

Several reasons explain why I believe this happened:

  • Hernandez was selected by Tudor Dixon, and it should be her choice to win or lose with him.
  • He was endorsed by Matt DePerno and Trump.
  • The alternative candidate would likely not strengthen the ticket, having run for Governor and received only 4% of the primary vote.
  • If the delegation installed a different Lieutenant Governor and the ticket lost, the blame would be hung around the neck of the grassroots and conservative movement.

In the end, this entire controversial debate demonstrated that the grassroots can indeed think rationally and strategically and restrain the instinct to burn down the house. Looking back to where this began with the grassroots, conservative, and tea party movement, we have come a long way in Michigan. Twelve to fifteen years ago, GOP state party conventions were probably 80% establishment and 20% conservative. That appears to have completely flipped. So where do we go from here? I think we need to look to the past to decide our future.

A Tribute to Three Conservative Women

A considerable sphere of conservative influence in the state was led by the Lakes Area Tea Party, Michigan Conservative Coalition, and Michigan Trump Republicans. We speak of the founding fathers of our nation, but these groups have three founding mothers — Meshawn Maddock, Marian Sheridan, and Rosanne Ponkowski. With some additional support, these women built a movement that began in Oakland County but spread across the state and helped produce the results at the August 2022 GOP Convention. Meshawn now serves as Co-Chair of the MIGOP, Marian as MIGOP Grass Roots Chair, and Rosanne as Vice Chair of the Oakland County Republican Party.

These three patriots have worked extremely hard for this movement. There is a saying that the wind blows highest at the top. I think all of us deserve both praise and criticism for what we say and do. However, I believe we need to temper criticism with the praise these women deserve. Meshawn in particular has received a great deal of critical commentary. Is this driven by a small percentage of the movement that amplifies its message through chats and social media? Could it be that 80% support most of what she does but do not stand up for her against the onslaught of negative criticism? I can tell you that the Establishment Swamp would like nothing more than to see Meshawn, Marian, and Rosanne go away. Is that what we really want?

Call me crazy, but with Meshawn we have someone who can call President Trump and he will pick up the phone. At the April 2022 endorsement convention, when Karamo and DePerno were confirmed, I did not see other politicians standing on stage uniting the party — but I did see Matt and Meshawn Maddock up there supporting them. Many women would have packed their bags and gone home, withdrawing from the fight, but these women did not. They have persevered because they are worried about their children and grandchildren, given the national spiral downward from the tried-and-true principles espoused by the founding fathers.

Explore More from MC4EI

Contact Us

Stay Connected

Follow MC4EI across our social channels to keep up with our latest work.

Site Information

For readers who want to dig deeper into the issues raised here, MC4EI's Learning Center and Reports Archive offer additional context on Michigan elections and grassroots organizing. You can also follow MC4EI on social media to stay informed as new reflections and reports are published.